Bakhtin/“Bakhtin”: The Archives and Beyond

An issue of: South Atlantic Quarterly

Journal Issue Volume 97, Number 3-4 Published: 1998 An issue of South Atlantic Quarterly
Offering original research on Mikhail Bakhtin by leading scholars in the field, this special issue of SAQ both celebrates the recent centennial of Bakhtin’s birth and elaborates significant new strains in Bakhtinian thinking. The distinction between Bakhtin and “Bakhtin” is a measure of the incommensurable space between the biographically verifiable figure and the one who emerges from contemporary critical applications of his work. While the inevitability of this space must be acknowledged, so too must its implications for a politics of culture where theory is concerned. Can there be a real Bakhtin, and can this one simply be the relevant Bakhtin? Is the deified Bakhtin just a reified Bakhtin?
Exploring both the dynamism of Bakhtin versus “Bakhtin” and the dynamics of “possible Bakhtins,” the contributors tackle this theorist’s range of shifting shapes, from the carnival-messianistic and the chronotopic, through the philosophic and the ideologic, to the “applied Bakhtin” of the social sciences. Bakhtin’s texts are examined in the context of work by such disparate figures as Ernst Cassirer and Rudolph Rocker, while various aspects of the academic “Bakhtin industry” are examined, including the “will to mythology by anthology” and the inequities of a world market in ideas exemplified by the resource gap between Russian and Western scholarship. The “state of the archive” is assessed by both UK Bakhtin Centre Director David Shepherd and Russian Bakhtin Archivist Nikolai Pan’kov. Throughout the issue, which is framed by Peter Hitchcock’s introductory polemics and Michael Holquist’s afterword, author and archive are continually deconstructed and reconstructed.

Contributors. Robert Barsky, Rachel Falconer, Maroussia Hadjukowski-Ahmed, Ken Hirschkop, Peter Hitchcock, Michael Holquist, Vitaly Makhlin, Nikolai Pan’kov, Brian Poole, David Shepherd, Galin Tihanov, Anthony Wall


To subscribe to this journal visit the South Atlantic Quarterly page.

Price: $24.00
Request a desk or exam copy

Table of Contents Back to Top

1. Introduction: Bakhtin/”Bakhtin”–Peter Hitchcock

2. Bakhtin and Cassirer: The Philosophical Origins of Bakhtin's Carnival Messianism—Brian Poole, Peter Hitchcock

3. Bakhtin Myths, or, Why We All Need Alibis—Ken Hirschkop, Peter Hitchcock

4. Volosinov, Ideology, and Language: The Birth of Marxist Sociology from the Spirit of Lebensphilosophie—Galin Tihanov, Peter Hitchcock

5. Bakhtin as Anarchist? Language, Law and Creative Impulses in the Work of Mikhail Bakhtin and Rudolf Rocker—Robert F. Barsky, Peter Hitchcock

6. Bakhtin Without Borders: Participatory Action Research in the Social Sciences—Maroussia Hajdukowski-Ahmed, Peter Hitchcock

7. A Broken Thinker—Anthony Wall, Peter Hitchcock

8. Bakhtin's Chronotope and the Contemporary Short Story—Rachel Falconer, Peter Hitchcock

9. Archive Material on Bakhtin's Nevel Period—Nikolai Pan’kov, Peter Hitchcock

10. The Bakhtin Centre and the State of the Archive: An Interview with David Shepherd—Peter Hitchcock

11. Questions and Answers: Bakhtin from the Beginning, at the End of the Century—Vitalii Makhlin, Peter Hitchcock

12. Notes on Contributors

Additional InformationBack to Top