Graphic Pluralism

An issue of: Ethnohistory

Graphic Pluralism
Journal Issue Volume 57, Number 1 Published: 2010 An issue of Ethnohistory
Special Issue Editor(s): Frank L. Salomon, Sabine Hyland
This special issue of Ethnohistory examines how Amerindian graphic codes interacted with alphabetic writing in the colonial polities of the Americas. Expanding on the common understanding of writing, the issue introduces the term graphic pluralism to describe situations in which multiple systems of inscription were used in the same linguistic community. The contributors’ studies of graphic pluralism shed light on colonial interactions in North America, Mesoamerica, and South America, and on how both alphabets and indigenous systems helped form the basis of colonial control and resistance.

One contributor shows how the Spanish colonial powers and the traditional Maya nobility in the Yucatán struggled over alphabetic literacy and the continued use of hieroglyphics. Another contributor documents how the Natick speakers of Martha’s Vineyard adopted alphabetic literacy for their own purposes in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, incorporating writing as a tool of traditional governance. In another article, a Spanish translation is compared to the original Nahua text to show how the two versions provide very different views of the Spanish conquest of the city-state of Mexico-Tenochtitlán. Yet another contributor examines how competing language ideologies in the Andes were used to characterize khipus (Andean knotted strings) and alphabetic script.


To subscribe to this journal visit the Ethnohistory page.

Price: $15.00
Request a desk or exam copy

Table of Contents Back to Top

1. Guest Editors' Introduction—Frank Salomon and Sabine Hyland

2. Reading Anishinaabe Identities: Meaning and Metaphor in Nindoodem Pictographs—Heidi Bohaker.

3. The Pragmatics of Language Learning: Graphic Pluralism on Martha's Vineyard, 1660-1720—Kathleen J. Bragdon

4. Three Texts in One: Book XII of the Florentine Codex—Kevin Terraciano

5. Zapotec Time, Alphabetic Writing, and the Public Sphere—David Tavárez

6. Writing as Resistance: Maya Graphic Pluralism and Indigenous Elite Strategies for Survival in Colonial Yucatan, 1550-1750—John F. Chuchiak, IV

7. Indigenous American Polygraphy and the Dialogic Model of Media—Galen Brokaw

8. Numeral Graphic Pluralism in the Colonial Andes—Gary Urton

9. Sodomy, Sin, and String Writing: The Moral Origins of Andean Khipu—Sabine Hyland

10. Reflections on What Writing Means, Beyond What It "Says": The Political Economy and Semiotics of Graphic Pluralism in the Americas—Margaret Bender

Additional InformationBack to Top
ISBN Paperback: 978-0-8223-6725-3