The Rhetoric of Church and State

A Critical Analysis of Religion Clause Jurisprudence

The Rhetoric of Church and State

Book Pages: 184 Illustrations: Published: October 1995

Law, Religious Studies

During the middle of the twentieth century, the religiously informed communitarianism that had guided the Supreme Court’s decisions regarding the relationship between church and state was partially displaced by a new secular individualist discourse. In The Rhetoric of Church and State, Frederick Mark Gedicks argues that this partial and incomplete shift is the key to understanding why the Court has failed—and continues today to fail—to provide a coherent doctrine on church/state separation.
Gedicks suggests that the Supreme Court’s inconsistent decisions mirror a divergence in American society between an increasingly secular public culture and the primarily devout private lives of the majority of Americans. He notes that while the Court is committed to principles of secular individualism, it has repeatedly endorsed government actions that violate those principles—actions that would be far more justifiable under the discourse of religious communitarianism. The impossibility of reconciling the two discourses leaves the Court no choice but to efface—often implausibly—the religious nature of practices it deems permissible. Gedicks concludes that the road to a coherent religion clause doctrine lies neither in a return to religious communitarianism nor in its complete displacement by secular individualism, but in a yet-to-be-identified discourse that would attract popular support while protecting a meaningful measure of religious freedom.


"Gedick’s text is a forceful polemic, and his focus on normative problems is to be welcomed. . . . [V]aluable. . . ." — Jason C. Bivins , Religious Studies Review

"Frederick Gedicks is a highly regarded authority on the jurisprudence of the Constitution’s religion clauses. In this book he offers a cleanly-executed, helpful, and telling analysis of the Supreme Court’s tangled web of religion cases. A wide circle of readers will welcome his achievement." — Milner S. Ball, University of Georgia School of Law

"Gedicks provides us with a full account of what are the most important issues in the religion clause debate and a fair and comprehensive overview of the Supreme Court jurisprudence. This is an excellent work." — William P. Marshall, Case Western Reserve University School of Law


Availability: In stock
Price: $24.95

Open Access

Author/Editor Bios Back to Top

Frederick Mark Gedicks is Professor of Law at Brigham Young University. He is coauthor with Roger Hendrix of Choosing the Dream: The Future of Religion in American Public Life.

Table of Contents Back to Top
Sales/Territorial Rights: World

Rights and licensing
Additional InformationBack to Top
Paper ISBN: 978-0-8223-1666-4 / Cloth ISBN: 978-0-8223-1654-1
Publicity material